What do you do when base housing lets you down?


(Photo: US Marines)

After a horrific series of events, residents of one major military base are wondering how to respond when the base and the Housing Office appear to send falsehoods in their official notices.

One of the biggest problems with base housing today is that it leaves military families as pawns between government agencies and private companies, with no one looking out for the family’s best interest. The Department of Defense owns and oversees housing on all military bases. But private property management companies such as Lincoln Military Housing, Hunt, or Balfour Beatty handle the overall maintenance of base homes.

What can military families do if they think their base or housing company is lying to them?

Failed water quality inspection

Families on Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton are asking that question. Last week was a disgusting and frustrating time for military families living there. I know, because I am one of those disgusted residents. News broke that the base failed a water quality inspection in June. The reasons for the failure were shocking: People listed as inspectors didn’t know they were inspectors, one tank hadn’t been cleaned since 2009, and worst of all, dead rats and frogs were found in water treatment tanks.

The news was publicized through outletslike the San Diego Tribune to the Marine Corps Times. Thousands of military families residing on the base saw the news and shared or discussed it on Facebook. Camp Pendleton had to do damage control.

Their response? Camp Pendleton emailed a letter to base residents stating that “your drinking water is safe and compliant.” The letter noted that the base failed the June water inspection because “reservoirs were found vulnerable to intrusion.” The letter assured residents that there was no need to boil water, that all reservoirs would be visually inspected within the next 30 days, and that an expert contractor would inspect and clean all water system reservoirs within 180 days.

That means base water will be back to EPA standards sometime within the next six months. Until then, no one knows if the water is actually safe to drink, no matter what an email letter says. There are water filters on public base water fountains. Maintenance workers have reportedly told residents, “I shouldn’t tell you this, but please don’t drink the water. It’s not good.” Many residents pay $50 per month for home water filtration systems.

Termites in base housing

Unfortunately for base residents, that wasn’t the end of the bad news. On September 26, one resident used Facebook Live to show a termite swarm crawling on her daughter’s bedroom floor and clothing. She was frustrated that Housing hadn’t done anything to treat the obvious infestation.

The resident, Tiffany Vilcheck, reported the termites to Housing three times starting on September 12, after she noticed them “pouring out of the stucco in clumps.” Lincoln Military Housing sprayed the house exterior for ants and roaches, but did nothing to treat termites. The night of the video, the resident called Housing around 7 PM to report a termite swarm in her toddler’s room. She said she was told that her request was not urgent. She waited several hours for a call back, which didn’t come until after 10 PM. By that time, her video was already going viral and had been seen by thousands of families on base. Within days, it was viewed over 200,000 times.

Although Lincoln Military Housing eventually offered the family a brand new home on base, the video caused an outpouring of grievances from base residents. Families complained on base Facebook pages about untreated mold issues, ignored water leaks, and houses without air conditioning that became dangerously hot for babies. Many tagged Lincoln Military Housing and said they had reported issues to the housing office but nothing had been done.

Lincoln Military Housing sent an email that went to all base residents. Lincoln Military Housing’s rep wrote, “We are sorry for [that family’s] experience and while Lincoln Military Housing did reach out and offer alternate housing for that evening, within an hour of being notified of the swarm, we also understand that this was certainly a less than ideal situation for their family.”

When I asked Vilcheck how she felt about the misstatements in the official letter, she shrugged them off. “They’re just covering themselves, everyone knows that. Let them say whatever they want. I’m just glad that—for us—this nightmare is over.”

For many base residents, however, the nightmare is just beginning. Families are asking whether it is safe to live on base with such questionable sanitation standards. If base officials say there is no problem when there clearly is an issue, how can anyone believe the base will inform them of a future issue?

Experiencing unsafe living conditions?

Military families facing unsafe living conditions on base have several options. They can contact the service member’s chain of command and alert them of non-responses from the Housing Office. Families can also contact the housing company’s regional management office, or they can take issues to the Family Housing Liaison from the military’s Family Housing Office. Ultimately, the Family Housing Office helped the Vilcheck family get a new home on base and secure movers to help them.

There is also the option to live off-base. It may be more expensive, but it’s a lot harder for a landlord to ignore dead animals in the water and termite swarms in the bedrooms.

By Lizann Lightfoot

2 Comments

  1. I feel like the so called management companies think they are safe with whatever they do with any type of reprimanding … I mean they should be held to a higher standards because us living on base … think about they automatically get a rent check with question without having to out and work to much for it … I mean our government provides the homes and they should be able to keep up with not just good but outstanding living conditions not this BS that we have all endured it’s dumb

  2. I lived in “coral rose” on Barbers Point in Hawaii in the early and mid 90’s. There was something growing in our units through the walls. My husband was on deployment so thinking since I was a valid ID holder and a resident myself I thought mistakenly that I could handle things myself. Housing would come out in groups and look at it, then they would scrape it off the walls and paint over it. Two weeks later it would be back. All I wanted was for them to test it, if it was something bad I would move and if it was nothing to worry about then that would be that. They came and duct taped plastic sheeting to my walls, nice and safe with a 4 year old. That actually came down on me one night while I was sleeping and I was sure someone was trying to kill me! My neighbor had the same thing and had a base sponsored daycare and they shut her down and moved her into another housing area all together because her husband’s command finally became involved. My thinking was if they shut down a daycare because of it how bad is it living 24/7 with it? As soon as my husband returned from his deployment he became a geo batchelor living in the beq and my daughter and I moved to the mainland for the duration of his tour on Hawaii. Was the stuff growing in our house bad for us? We will never know but I personally have several auto immune issues, arthritis, fibromyalgia and a host of other problems and it is always on my mind “I wonder….”

Comments are closed.